Skip to main content

BS 9992 or BS 9999: which code governs your fire strategy?

Rail infrastructure or buildings? How to tell whether BS 9992:2020 or BS 9999:2017 governs your fire strategy, and where one code refers to the other.

By JWCS Consultancy. Published . Last reviewed .

  • BS 9992
  • BS 9999
  • Fire strategy
  • Approved Document B
  • London Underground

BS 9992:2020 and BS 9999:2017 have almost the same title. One is Fire safety in the design, management and use of rail infrastructure; the other is Fire safety in the design, management and use of buildings. Both are codes of practice, and they are not interchangeable. Choosing the governing code is one of the first decisions in a fire strategy, and a wrong choice at concept stage sets the escape design, the fire resistance and the materials against the wrong benchmarks. This note explains how to tell which code governs, and where one refers to the other.

Start with the premises, not the code

The code follows from what the premises is. A railway station is rail infrastructure, and BS 9992:2020 covers it: its scope includes surface, sub-surface and enclosed stations. An office, a shop or another non-residential building falls under BS 9999:2017, or under Approved Document B Volume 2, the approved guidance on meeting the fire safety requirements of the Building Regulations for buildings other than dwellings in England. Dwellings, blocks of flats and the other residential buildings within its scope have their own code of practice, BS 9991:2024; Approved Document B Volume 1 covers dwellings.

So the first step is to designate the premises and, on a mixed site, each part of it. The code is then selected by scope.

How the two codes work

BS 9992:2020 is organised around the class of station. Its recommendations differ for surface, enclosed and sub-surface stations. Escape capacity is tested against two scenarios specific to the railway, a fire on a train in the station and a fire within the station structure (Clause 14.6). Sub-surface and enclosed stations are designed so that platforms can be cleared within 4 minutes, with travel from the most remote point on the platform to a place of ultimate safety or a protected route within 6 minutes. Surface stations are designed so that platforms can be cleared within 8 minutes and occupants cleared to a place of ultimate safety within 12 minutes. Elements of structure are recommended to achieve R 60, R 90 or R 120 according to the class of station, whether or not sprinklers are installed (Clause 44.2.1).

BS 9999:2017 is organised around a risk profile. The risk profile combines an occupancy characteristic, which reflects whether the occupants are familiar with the building and whether they are likely to be awake or asleep (Clause 6.2, Table 2), with a fire growth rate (Clause 6.3, Table 3). It sets the means of escape and the other life safety design features (Clause 6.1); Table 23, for example, sets fire resistance periods for elements of structure by risk profile and building height. BS 9999 has no platform clearance criterion and no train fire scenario.

Where BS 9992 refers to BS 9999

BS 9992:2020 complements BS 9999:2017. Where BS 9992 gives no recommendation of its own, its foreword points to BS 9999 for guidance, and several clauses refer to BS 9999 directly. For example:

  • at enclosed and sub-surface stations, travel distances refer to BS 9999:2017 Table 11 for the appropriate risk profile, with the exception of the platform (BS 9992:2020 Clause 14.4.1);
  • refuges within buildings follow BS 9999:2017 Annex G, and open-air platform refuges take its dimensions and safety features (BS 9992:2020 Clause 16.2); and
  • the fire resistance of roof structures follows BS 9999:2017 Clause 30.2.4 (BS 9992:2020 Clause 44.2.2).

Each reference imports the provision it names, with any exceptions BS 9992 sets out. None of them makes BS 9999 the governing code for the station: the class of station, the escape capacity criteria and the fire resistance periods stay with BS 9992. Cite each through the BS 9992 clause that makes the reference, so a reviewer can see why a buildings code appears in a railway fire strategy. Applying BS 9999 risk profiles to a platform, or the station criteria of BS 9992 to an office building, benchmarks the design against the wrong case.

Mixed sites

Many railway projects include building-type uses: station offices, retail units or a development above the station. BS 9992:2020 Clause 4.3 draws the line. Facilities that are independent of the station and separated from it by fire-resisting construction, such as retail premises, office space or training facilities, follow the relevant annexes of BS 9999:2017. Ancillary accommodation within the station, such as retail units, is designed as part of the station. In every case the railway premises should be able to operate independently of the non-railway parts, in normal use and in a fire. The interfaces need the most care: shared escape routes, the fire separation between the station and the building, and any fire safety systems that serve both.

On London Underground

TfL’s S1080 lists five codes of practice, BS 9992, BS 9999, Approved Document B Volume 2, CD 352 and BS 6266, “adopted according to the scope of the works” (Clause 3.3.1). It does not rank them. On a station, BS 9992 is the code that fits the scope. Each London Underground Category 1 standard then applies alongside the selected code by its own scope. A deviation from the selected code of practice is based on BS 7974 and described in the fire safety strategy (S1080 Clause 3.3.2 and its Note), and a planned or known departure from a London Underground standard needs an S1641 concession.

When neither code bounds the case

BS 9992:2020 notes in its foreword that a fire safety engineering approach to BS 7974 might suit some complex railway premises. Where the recommendations of the selected code do not bound the case, the design can be developed to BS 7974:2019, with the departure from the code stated plainly. That is a route away from the selected code, not a choice between BS 9992 and BS 9999 provision by provision.

A short checklist

  1. Designate the premises, and each part of a mixed site.
  2. Select the code by scope: BS 9992:2020 for railway stations; BS 9999:2017 or Approved Document B Volume 2 for non-residential buildings; BS 9991:2024 for dwellings, blocks of flats and the other residential types in its scope, with Approved Document B Volume 1 for dwellings.
  3. Where BS 9992 refers to BS 9999 for a provision, cite it through that reference.
  4. Do not treat the two codes as alternatives to choose between, provision by provision.
  5. State the route for any departure from the selected code.

How JWCS helps

We prepare fire strategies for railway stations under BS 9992:2020, and fire strategy reports for buildings other than dwellings under BS 9999:2017 and Approved Document B Volume 2. The governing code is selected by premises class, and the frameworks are held distinct. More on how we work: BS 9992 fire strategy for railway stations, fire strategy design and buildings.

This note is general guidance, not project-specific advice. Check the current editions of the standards and the requirements of your project before relying on it.

Related services

  • BS 9992 Fire Strategy for Railway Stations

    Fire strategies for new railway stations and for existing stations in service, under BS 9992:2020, the code of practice for fire safety in rail infrastructure.

  • Fire Strategy Design

    Fire strategy design: railway premises under BS 9992:2020, and buildings other than dwellings under BS 9999:2017 and Approved Document B Volume 2.

← All insights

Need fire engineering support?

Senior-led from the first conversation.

Contact